Here's an article talking about a wolf vs. dog study...link

Post Canine health, behavior, and veterinary questions here
Post Reply
User avatar
Mary Plummer
Posts: 908
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 8:29 am
Location: Michigan

Here's an article talking about a wolf vs. dog study...link

Post by Mary Plummer »

Hello everyone,

I know we've talked about studies demonstrating dogs' ability to read human facial expressions, etc., but I don't remember one comparing their ability to do this to wolves. What this makes me wonder is just how researchers define what makes an animal "smart". It seems like there are a number of different ways we could define it for dogs, and I'm just not sure how it is most commonly used.

http://dsc.discovery.com/news/briefs/20 ... gwolf.html
User avatar
TheSkeptic
Posts: 1703
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2003 8:56 am
Location: LaPlace LA

It depends...

Post by TheSkeptic »

Coren uses those things that can be tested imperically....

Memory. ...

A: Show teh dog something he really likes.
B: Let him see you put it somewhere.
C: Take him away for a period of time.
D: Take him back and see if he goes to the place you put the item.

Problem solving.

A: Show the dog something he really likes.
B: Let him see you put it somewhere where it would be difficult for him to get it.
C; see if he can solve the problem of retrieving the object.
User avatar
momPaws
Posts: 3540
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2003 8:13 am
Location: Beautiful USA

Doggy IQ

Post by momPaws »

I saw a show on Animal Planet once that showed a dog IQ test. Some of the tests were things so simple for Honey...like... put a hankie on the dog's head and see what they do. Some dogs actually just sat there covered up..but if you had a smart dog they would, of course, shake it off in a sec.

Another one was to turn an object upside down - like in Honey's case either a hamb. roll or frosty paws cup - and time how long it takes for them to right the object. This is nothing for her to do.

Wish I could remember the others, so I guess since I can't I flunk the test :lol: :lol:
User avatar
momPaws
Posts: 3540
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2003 8:13 am
Location: Beautiful USA

PS

Post by momPaws »

oops..just remembered (cheated and looked at Skeptic's post) - those were there, too...hiding and object, etc. It was a very interesting test when you saw the variations in how the different dogs reacted.
User avatar
newfie
Posts: 35
Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2003 8:30 am
Location: Wi
Contact:

Post by newfie »

Half those IQ tests especially on animal planet are horrible at finding a motiviator for the correct dog, for instance a mastiff, was considered low on the intelligence scale becouse he didnt go after the rubber squeek toy, how awful.
they are intelligent,
find them a REAL motivator and you will SEE how intelligent they really are.
why didnt they try food or something really enticing?
sometimes i swear they love to set up a particular breed to fail and make others shine.
LOL
oh and the blankee test i laughed at, many people cover their dogs up and they lay on the bed with them, it is comforting for many dogs to be under a blankee, that to me does not show intelligence, take them into the field of SAR or some other working test than we will see how intelligent they REALLY are
User avatar
Amandasmom
Posts: 643
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2003 5:04 am
Location: Massachusetts

Article in Science

Post by Amandasmom »

This article was in the November issue of Science. It said dogs are better at picking up clues from humans then chimps. A chimp will follow the gaze of other chimps or humans but a dog will understand pointing or taps and a chimp can't. I didn't think about this until I read the article. I'll point to Pete's toy and he will go get it. But when I point at something for the cat, he doesn't understand. It's realy neat.
Post Reply